Office of the Commissioner for Enviromental InformationOffice of the Commissioner for Enviromental InformationOffice of the Commissioner for Enviromental Information
  • Gaeilge
  • Switch to Gaeilge
  • Making an Appeal
    • Who can appeal
    • How to appeal
    • Make an appeal
  • Decisions
  • Law
    • Legislation
    • Court judgments
    • Environmental information
  • Resources
  • Publications
    • Annual reports
    • Press releases
    • Submissions
  • About
    • Who we are
    • What we do
    • How we do it
    • FOI publication scheme
    • Accessible services
  • Contact

Decisions

  1. Home
  2. Decisions

Refine by:


Padraig O'Reilly and EirGrid PLC (EirGrid)

The Commissioner found that EirGrid did not make any decision on much of the information captured by part 1 of the request. Given the close relationship between the information captured by parts 1 and 2, the Commissioner considered that both of those parts must be considered together. Accordingly, he annulled EirGrid?s decision on those parts of the request and required EirGrid to make a fresh decision in accordance with the Regulations.

Date

29th July 2019

Case Number

CEI/19/0001

Public Body

EirGrid PLC

Article of the Regulations

Art.7

Mr XY and Fingal County Council

The Commissioner found that while article 9(1)(c) applied to the information, the public interest in disclosure outweighed the interests served by refusal. Accordingly, he annulled the Council's decision and required it to make the withheld environmental information available to the appellant.

Date

10th July 2019

Case Number

CEI/18/0027

Public Body

Fingal County Council

Article of the Regulations

Art.9

Noonan Linehan Carroll Coffey Solicitors and An Bord Pleanála (the Board)

The Commissioner found that refusal to provide access to the requested information was justified on the ground of article 8(a)(iv) of the AIE Regulations. Accordingly, he affirmed the Board?s decision and did not require it to take any action.

Date

8th July 2019

Case Number

CEI/19/0004

Public Body

An Bord Pleanála

Article of the Regulations

Art.8,Art.8(a)(iv)

Mr A and Galway County Council (the Council)

The Commissioner found that in the circumstances of this case the Council was justified in granting access to the information sought in two planning enforcement files by making them available for inspection at its office in accordance with article 7(3)(a)(ii) of the AIE Regulations. He varied the Council's decision to include an additional seven enforcement files which, during the course of the Commissioner's review, the Council offered to provide the appellant access to, by also making them available for inspection at its office.

Date

1st July 2019

Case Number

CEI/18/0017

Public Body

Galway County Council

Article of the Regulations

Art.7

Mr Q and Kilkenny County Council (the Council)

The Commissioner found that the Council was not justified in refusing access to the road safety audit reports. He found that they are environmental information under article 3(1)(c). He further found that refusal of access to the safety audit reports under article 8(a)(iv) of the AIE Regulations was not justified. Accordingly, he required the Council to release the reports. In addition, he found that as the Council had not carried out an adequate search for the draft reports and correspondence sought, it was not justified in refusing access to that information. He remitted that part of the request back to the Council and expressed his expectation that it would make a new decision on it, in accordance with the AIE Regulations. The Commissioner also found that the Council was justified under article 7(5) of the Regulations in refusing access to information relating to a meeting between Council staff and An Garda Síochána on the basis the information was not held by or for it. Accordingly, he affirmed the Council's decision on that part of the request.

Date

26th June 2019

Case Number

CEI/18/0014

Public Body

Kilkenny County Council

Article of the Regulations

Art.3,Art.8

Right to Know CLG and the Office of the Secretary General to the President (the OSGP)

The Commissioner found that, in the circumstances of this case, Article 13.8.1° of the Constitution precludes the Council of State and the OSGP from being subject to the review procedure under Article 6 of the AIE Directive. He found that for the purposes of this review, neither the OSGP nor the Council of State is a public authority within the meaning of article 3 of the AIE Regulations, as amended by S.I. No. 309 of 2018 European Communities (Access to Information on the Environment) (Amendment) Regulations 2018. Accordingly, he found that he has no jurisdiction to review the OSGP's decision on this AIE request.

Date

17th June 2019

Case Number

CEI/17/0033

Public Body

Secretary General to the President

Article of the Regulations

Art.3,Art.3(2)

Dr Ted Nealon and the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)

The Commissioner found that some of the withheld information was outside of the scope of his review because it fell outside of the date-range specified by the appellant. He noted that the appellant excluded three of the withheld records from the scope of his appeal. The Commissioner found that the remaining withheld information does not constitute or contain environmental information. Accordingly, he affirmed the EPA?s decision while amending the reasons for refusal to reflect his findings.

Date

6th June 2019

Case Number

CEI/18/0047

Public Body

Environmental Protection Agency

Article of the Regulations

Art.3,Art.7,Art.8,Art.9

Ms Fand Cooney and Coillte Teoranta (Coillte)

The Commissioner was not satisfied that Coillte adequately responded to this AIE request or that its decision was justified. He therefore annulled Coillte?s decision and required it to process the request afresh. He considered that the parties should engage with one another so that, if the appellant wishes to pursue the request, there could be greater clarity as to what environmental information is both sought and held, and if access to requested information is refused, greater clarity as to the reasons for that refusal.

Date

6th June 2019

Case Number

CEI/18/0049

Public Body

Coillte Teoranta (Coillte)

Article of the Regulations

Art.10,Art.3,Art.7,Art.8,Art.9

Right to Know CLG & the Department of Defence

The Commissioner found that the Department was not justified in refusing the appellant?s request. He found that the information on the dates of travel, departure point and destination, flying time and the number of passengers is environmental information under article 3(1)(c). He found that the information on the departure point and destination, and the dates of those journeys, is environmental information under article 3(1)(b). The Commissioner did not accept the assertion that the information is excluded from the scope of the AIE Regulations on the basis that it relates to the President. He was also not satisfied that article 8(a)(i), 8(a)(ii) or 9(1)(a) applied to the information as claimed. Accordingly, he annulled the Department's decision and required it to make the information available to the appellant.

Date

30th May 2019

Case Number

CEI/16/0041

Public Body

Department of Defence (the Department)

Article of the Regulations

Art.3,Art.8,Art.9

Mr N and Kilkenny County Council (the Council)

Having carried out a review in accordance with article 12(5) of the AIE Regulations, the Commissioner varied the Council's decision. He found that refusal of information on contractor designed temporary and permanent works was justified under article 9(1)(c). However, he required release of redacted versions of two Method Statements for the construction of cofferdams in accordance with article 10(5).

Date

29th May 2019

Case Number

CEI/17/0039

Public Body

Kilkenny County Council

Article of the Regulations

Art.10,Art.10(5),Art.9,Art.9(1)(c)

  • Back
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10
  • 11
  • 12
  • 13
  • 14
  • Page 10 of 26
  • Next
The Office of the Commissioner for               Environmental Information
The Office of the Commissioner for Environmental Information
6 Earlsfort Terrace, Dublin 2, D02 W773.

Opening Hours: 9.15 to 5.00 Monday to Friday

  • Make an FOI request to OCEI
  • Make an AIE request to OCEI
  • Re-use of OCEI Information
  • Regulation of Lobbying Act 2015
  • Irish Language Scheme
  • gov.ie
  • Strategy & governance
  • Customer Service
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy & cookies
  • Contact