Summary of Commissioner's Decision: The Commissioner found that the request does not relate to information on emissions into the environment as per article 10(1). He found, after weighing the public interest in accordance with article 10(3), that article 9(1)(c) justifies the non-disclosure of the withheld information. As that was his finding, it was not necessary for him to consider article 8(a)(iv). Accordingly, the Commissioner did not require the Department to make environmental information available to the appellant.