The Commissioner found that:
(a) The scope of the request does not include documents which impact on, or are incorporated by reference into, the PPP contract;
(b) The PPP contract as a whole is environmental information;
(c) TII was not justified in refusing access to the PPP contract on the grounds that the request is manifestly unreasonable; and
(d) It is not appropriate in this case to exercise the power in article 12(5)(c), so TII must give fresh consideration to the appellants request for information